Monday, January 29, 2007

Mongolia | 1997 | Total Solar Eclipse

The last Solar Eclipse in Mongolia was on March 9, 1997. Here is my account of that momentous event:

I will admit that the line about the total eclipse of the sun from the Carly Simon song was running through my head as our Mongolian Airlines 737 landed in Ulaan Baatar, the capital of Mongolia. The center line of the total solar eclipse scheduled for March 9 was passing near the city of Darkhan 136 miles north of Ulaan Baatar and I planned to be there.

Exactly sixty-seven hours and ten minutes earlier I had left Anchorage on Korean Airlines, and after a three hour layover in Seoul had continued on to Beijing. At one o'clock in the afternoon in Beijing several thousand people were still amassed in Tianamen Square, many still holding pictures of Deng Xiaoping, whose funeral service before a crowd of 10,000 in the Great Hall of the People had ended only two hours before. In my outrageously expensive hotel room I tuned in CNN International and listened to several pundits in Hong Kong ponder the future of China. They cautiously predicted a smooth transition of power but agreed outsiders know little more about the hermetic councils of the Chinese Communist Party than they do about the inner courts of the Qing and Ming. No one could say what conflicts might be brewing in the world’s most populous nation. This brought to mind, not Carly Simon, but John Milton and his lines from “Paradise Lost”:

As when the sun, newly risen,
Looks through the horizontal misty air
Shorn of his beams . . .
In dim eclipse, disastrous twilight sheds
On half the nations and with fear of change
Perplexes monarchs.

At least from the time of the Babylonians 4000 years ago eclipses, comets, and other celestial phenomena have been considered portents of the death of kings, political and social upheavals, and all manner of other man-made and natural catastrophes and disasters. We were in for a double dip on March 9; for the first time since 1948 a comet would be visible to the naked eye during the totality of the eclipse. This was the comet Hale-Bopp, which some astrologers were calling the “Comet of the Century”, and which had already whipped up a firestorm of controversy in its own right.

Cataclysms aside, the eclipse promised to be the biggest tourist event in Mongolia since the arrival of the Polo Brothers. The cab driver on the eleven mile run into town told me that city officials had first anticipated 8,000 to 10,000 eclipse gazers from all over the world, but had recently down scaled the estimate to 2500, still a lot for a country which hosted a total of 4000 American tourists in all of 1996.

Celebrities were expected. In February the Mongolian newspaper Tol breathlessly reported: ”Madonna, a renowned pop singer from the United States, will visit Mongolia in March to watch the solar eclipse. Madonna learned about Mongolia from Hollywood star Richard Gere who came here last August accompanying Dalai Lama. An emissary of Madonna came recently to study the local travel and accommodation conditions. It is expected that Madonna will arrive on her private plane on March 8 and stay overnight. It's still unclear whether Madonna will bring along her newborn.”

Shortly afterwards a rumor washed over Ulaan Baatar that Bill Gates would be in town for the eclipse. No one in authority could confirm or deny these reports; perhaps they were just variants of Elvis sightings, a form of low level hysteria brought about by uncritical exposure to the American celebrity-making media machine. Still, interest in the eclipse among even the hoi polloi of America was feverish. Montana-based horse wrangler and international gadabout Kent Madin, who in recent years had become a magnate in Mongolian tourism, told me before I left that he had over ninety clients signed up—he could have got more but he couldn't guarantee them hotel room—and that his group plus staff would almost fill one of the six special Mongolian Airlines flights from Beijing to Ulaan Baatar scheduled for the two days before the eclipse.

With the help of my cab driver I was soon ensconsced in a $6 a night dump just up the street the palatial Chinggis Khaan Hotel, where rooms started at over a eighty dollars a night. Every reputable hotel in town was of course booked to the rafters for the week straddling the eclipse and my driver friend warned me that even this place would fill up in a couple of days. To make sure I wasn't left out in the cold—not a figure a speech here; it was –10°F my first morning in town—I paid for two weeks in advance. My quarters, while humble, were certainly roomy. The hotel was an old apartment building and for my six bucks a night I got a whole apartment—big living room, two bedrooms, kitchen, and bath. If you have ever been in cheesier examples of Khrushchev-era Soviet apartments you get the idea.

On the sun-drenched morning of February 26 the flanks of Bogd Кhan Uul, the mountain massif that looms above the southern edge of the city, are glistening with fresh-fallen snow as I walk down the street to the Chinggis Khaan, a new ten-story 182 room hotel of Xanaduian proportions and design. On the monumental steps leading to the entrance four Mongolian men are brooming off fresh snow. The huge lobby is deserted except for one young women at the reception desk. The fifth floor dining room, with a spectacular view of the Bogd Khan Uul through a wall of glass, is a sea of gleaming white table cloths. Only two tables are occupied. “You will have eggs,” the waitress informs me. Two eggs over-easy, toast, jam, and instant coffee cost $5.00. The waitress says a total of forty people are staying in the huge hotel, mostly businessmen and their paramours.

In the afternoon I walk downtown and circle expansive Sukhe Baatar Square, with its statue of Sukhe Baatar, the communist hero of the Mongolian Revolution, mounted on a rearing stead. A quick check in the Museum of Natural History, where the dinosaur exhibitions are a sure-fire magnet for tourists, and several other museums, followed by dinner at the Bayangol Hotel and a troll through several watering holes supposedly favored by foreigners confirms that no more than a handful of the expected horde of eclipsers have yet invaded.

By March 1 I detect a gabble of languages ringing through the stairwells of my hovel: American and British English, German, French, Japanese, and assorted unknowns. This is the student-aged economy-class crowd. The main topic of conversation among the young men is where to buy beer and score chicks. A few days later a big group of incredibly boisterous Singapore Chinese arrive. They take over the canteen on the floor below and not until after four in the morning does their singing and shouting die down.

Unable to sleep I bundle up and go out to the large school yard just behind the hotel. Since my arrival in Ulaan Baatar I had been trying without success to see the Comet Hale-Bopp. Either I had passed out from exhaustion in the wee hours or the skies had been overcast. Now as I rounded the corner of the hotel and looked up I instantly spotted the comet hanging high in the east-north-east sky.

Even comets with great potential have been known to fizzle out and disappoint earth-bound viewers, but if Hale-Bopp lived up to its early billing it was shaping up as the brightest visitor to pass inside the Earth's orbit since the great comet reported by Tycho Brahe in 1577. And if all went according to plan it would become visible to the naked eye during the March 9 eclipse's period of totality. This happening last on November 1 1948 during an eclipse in Kenya, and before that on May 17 1882, when a comet was observed during totality of an eclipse in Egypt. Hale-Bopp would approach to within 196 million kilometers of Earth on March 22 before zooming off into the cosmos, but already during the first week of March I could easily detect its notorious twin-pronged tail which had helped spawn the Hale-Bopp companion imbroglio.

The fuss started when Chuck Shramek, an amateur astronomer in Houston, Texas, took a photograph which apparently showed a strange Saturn-like object following in the comet's wake. He posted the photo on the Internet and announced his findings on the late-night radio talk show "Coast to Coast AM", hosted by Art Bell, a tireless promoter of a doomsday scenario he calls The Quickening. Immediately the Internet was throbbing with speculation: the object was a alien space craft which was closely following Hale-Bopp and leaving its own tail; it was causing Hale-Bopp to change course; it was emitting radio signals; the government had Hubble Space Telescope photos of the companion and was sand-bagging; and on and on. Professional astronomers quickly retorted on-line and elsewhere that Shramek had gears loose in his gyro and that the “unknown” object was actually a mundane star designated SAO 141894 on celestial maps.

The Hale-Bopp companion caper took an even more bizarre turn when one Courtney Brown, a proponent of “scientific remote viewing” —New Age jargon for clairvoyance—announced on the Art Bell show that his remote viewers had detected in the comet’s wake a larger-than-earth hollow sphere apparently controlled by a superior intelligence and filled with billions of aliens whose intentions toward Earth were probably not all that benign. The sphere was sending out radio signals and of course there was a government cover-up.

Then "Major" Ed Dames, also a remote viewing tout who claims to have worked for sundry U.S. intelligence agencies, appeared on the Art Bell Show and dismissed Brown's claims as pure hooey. He went on—apparently with a straight face; it's hard to tell on radio—to propound his own theory: certain cosmic intelligences, knowing that Hale-Bopp was going to pass relatively close to Earth, had attached to it a cylindrical object programmed to spew out a pathogen which would destroy almost all the planet's vegetation. Why, you might ask? It seems these cosmic intelligences view human beings as little more than a bad case of acne on the face of the Earth and that by administering an antibiotic—in this case a plant pathogen which will destroy human food sources—the Earth will be cured. Why not a pathogen that destroys human beings directly? Don't ask. Anyhow, the pathogen will fall on Africa first in 1998 and then spread wildly over the planet. Only 20% of the human population will survive the final cut. Thoroughly chastised, the survivors will presumably abstain from fossil fuels, spray deodorants, and non-returnable beer cans.

For weeks these and other doomsday scenarios roiled on the Internet and insomniac talk shows and finally even slithered into the mainstream media, including the San Diego Mercury News, MSNBC, and even the Washington Post, whose reporter portentously labeled the whole mess a “splintering of a consensual reality” by “the radio-cyberspace paradigm factory.”

Mongolians, blithely unaware of the comet companion brouhaha, have their own fish to fry; namely, how to extract as much money as possible from the whole eclipse-comet configuration. Not content with the money dumped into airlines, hotels, restaurants, gift shops, brothels, and other service industries, the Eclipse Planning Committee has levied a $10 fee on foreigners entering the "eclipse zone"—Mongolians pay 2000 tögrögs, $2.50. For this you get an eclipse badge which you are required to wear while in Darkhan. Plus there is a tariff for all vehicles entering the eclipse zone—$15.00 for those carrying foreigners and 5,000 tg for those carrying locals. Most eye-popping is a $25,000 to $40,000 fee for taking video or motion picture film of the eclipse—it's unclear whether this applies only to outfits like CNN and big-time documentary makers or also to Ma and Pa Kettle with a mini-cam. Then if you are really worried about the weather you can fly above any potential eclipse-blocking cloud cover in a Mongolian Airlines 737—$2,500 for a thirty minute flight straddled around totality—and if you don't want to rub noses with the rabble on the 737 you can charter your own Russian AN - 24 airplane for $800 an hour.

In Ulaan Baatar a welter of activities were laid on to lure in eclipsers on their way to and from Darkhan. Predictably the mainstays of the city's performing arts—the Theater of Opera and Ballet, the State Drama Theater, the Ensemble of National Song and Dance, and the State Circus—all planned special performances. But the most over-the-top event was the "Great Khaan's Dinner Show" to be held at the Chinggis Khaan Hotel. While consuming a four-course Great Khaan Meal" complete with the "Great Khaan's favorite vodka," diners were to be entertained with selections by a violin ensemble and a folk song and dance group; a set by Saraa, Mongolia's reigning "Queen of Pop Music"; a fashion show by Soyolmaa, Mongolia's leading fashion designer, featuring Mongolia's top models (namely Ariunaa, Zulaa, Undraa, Boloroo, Tuya, and Oyanaa); a demonstration by Khongorzul, Mongolia's top female contortionist, a cameo appearance by "Mr. Mongolia"; and last but hardly least, a pack of performing wolves directed by famed—in Mongolia—animal trainer Amgalan. All this cost a mere $70 per person. What led the producers of this extravaganza to conclude that visitors, especially the type likely to be attracted to something as arcane as an eclipse, would willingly shell out a seventy bucks for a dinner show, even one featuring trained wolves and a contortionist, is unclear.

Not everyone regarded the eclipse as a cash cow to be milked. The Buddhist community in particular was less than sanguine. According to Buddhist legend eclipses are caused by the unleashing of Rakh, the god of chaos and destruction. All of Ulaan Baatar's monasteries were planning services of counteract the eclipse's baleful influence. In a statement released to the media—he was unavailable for interviews—Lama Sh. Soninbayar, a teacher at the Gandan Buddhist University in Ulaan Baatar, said, “The solar eclipse is not a holiday or a celebration for Mongolia's Buddhists. We will chant special Sutras during the eclipse—the Doded, Jambatsanjod, and the Thousand Taras are used during times such as these to protect people's lives and to try to instill peace in their minds during this calamity.” The lama also predicted that wild animals all across Mongolia, traumatized by the power of Rakh, would howl in pain during the eclipse and that human beings in any part of the world might resort to bizarre if not downright dangerous behavior in its aftermath.

Of course, not everybody bought into this take on Rakh. The bronze, silver, and gold commemorative medallions being sold to honor the eclipse featured a depiction of the sun being consumed by this very god of death and chaos.

Before leaving for Mongolia I had made arrangements with Boojum Expedition's silver-maned chieftain Kent Madin for transportation to the eclipse viewing sight at Darkhan, 136 miles north by road from Ulaan Baatar. In the event, this would not have been necessary, since Mongolian Airlines, which does not normally fly to Darkhan, had laid on at least nine special flights between Ulaan Baatar and the city, and seats were available right up until the last moment. Also were scheduled buses and trains between the two cities, plus free-lancers hauling passengers by car and van.

Nevertheless, I met the Boojumites when they arrived at the airport on the morning of March 7 and crowded onto one of their four big Japanese-made buses. The various astronomy magazines in the States had billed this eclipse as only for the most hardy souls willing and able to brave the frozen wastes of Mongolia in mid-winter, and I had supposed the group would be mainly rough and ready adventure travel types who also had a passing interest in astronomy. Instead many appeared to be retirees on their way to a winter vacation in Orlando, Florida who somewhere along the line had made a seriously wrong turn. True, there was a man from NASA leading of small sub-group of serious cosmos-heads (they haughtily ignored the rest of the Boojumites); a coterie of amateur eclipse chasers who apparently go to all total solar eclipses (Peru, Cambodia, and Hawaii were just a few of the more recent stops); a woman from the office of the Hubble Telescope and assorted techno-nerds, but many appeared to be simply joy riders; indeed, some were following up this jaunt with a boat trip on the Yangtze River.

After a pit stop in Ulaan Baatar for snacks, bottled water, and beer our caravan rolled north towards Darkhan, Mongolia's second largest city (pop. 86,000). Although this road is one of the main highways of Mongolia—it connects the capital with Darkhan and the Russian border— it is bumpy and narrow and we expect to take over five hours to cover the 136 miles to Darkhan. There is no snow for the first twenty or thirty miles, just flat or gently rolling expanses of sere steppe stretching off to jagged ridges miles in the distance. Scattered herds of thin cattle, some draped with blankets to protect them from the cold, and tightly bunched flocks of sheep wander the undulating plain, watched over by sentinels on horseback wearing long robes and immense fur hats or by shepherds on foot with long staffs. Occasionally we pass a lone ger - the round canvas tents in which Mongols live - or a small settlement of gers surrounded by corrals. At one point overflow from a small creek has covered the road with a thick hundred yard-long lens of ice which our buses detour around by driving across the steppe. It's no problem - the ground is smoother than the roughs of a lot of public golf courses and of course frozen as solid as concrete. As we move farther north more snow begins to accumulate on the northern sides of the foreground ridges and in the distance can be seen high, stark, completely white mountains. There are of course no facilities on the entire road. During rest stops woman go to the left side of the road and men to the right. The sight of over one hundred people relieving themselves on the Mongolian steppe is not edifying.

We arrive at the Darkhan Hotel in the dark. Assembled outside the entrance are several hundred Darkhanese gaping at the exotic foreigners. Husky Mongolian cops guard the doors, baying at locals trying to sneak into the hotel and heaving kids away from the entrance way by the scruff of the neck. Bedlam erupts as 110 guests crowd into the lobby. Elderly tourists screech for their luggage and room keys; one pre-Alzheimer's woman in her eighties has already lost her coat and hand-carry luggage; another old crone is having either an asthma attack or a heart seizure. The Mongolian receptionists are models of equanimity; some are old enough to have dealt with the cadres of drunken Russian apparatchiks who descended on this Soviet-planned industrial city and are thus unfazed by anything.

High on her speculative tower
Stood Science waiting for the hour
When Sol was destined to endure
That darkening of his radiant face
Which Superstition strove to chase,
Erewhile, with rites impure.

William Wordsworth, "The Eclipse of the Sun"

At four in the morning Hale-Bopp is clearly visible from the balcony of my room. Its two-pronged tail seems to have gotten even more pronounced in the last couple days. A few other insomniacs pad through the halls, and a small contingent of NASA types keeps vigil on the comet from the roof of the hotel. In a tiny temple on the second floor three young lamas from the Kharagiin Monastery in Darkhan quietly chant in front of several dozen flickering candles. By six a blanket of ice fog rolls in, blocking the view, and the night owls head for the dining room where the waitresses have laid out packets of instant coffee and thermos of hot water.
Young monks from Kharagiin Monastery
As soon as the sun rises I walk to the large ger camp behind the hotel where a contingent of monks from Gandan Monastery in Ulaan Baatar are chanting in a ger.
Ger camp set up at Darkhan especially for the eclipse
The ger camp catered to all needs: a bar with brothel on the side.
Near the ger camp monks have set up an outdoor altar surrounded by several long tables on which an old lama is arranging hundreds of small bronze lamps. The monk informs me in broken Russian that a "Thousand Lights" ceremony will be performed here tomorrow.
Lamps for the Thousand Lights Ceremony
Each of the lamps will be lit by the faithful in an attempt to drive away the bad vibes produced by the eclipse and instill peace in the souls of people not just in Mongolia but all over the world. When I hand my camera to a little Mongolian kid to take my picture standing next to the lamp tables the old monk quickly sidles up next to me and poses unasked.
Lighting lamps
While the monks fretted over people’s souls a trade mart was developing in front of the hotel. The driveway leading to the entrance was lined with people selling jackets and coats made by Darkhan's famous leather goods factories, including some spectacular ankle-length, multicolored models going for over $400; cashmere sweaters, scarves and gloves; fur hats, both cheap fox fur tourist knockoffs and pricier mink and wolf fur models; elaborately embroidered deels, the long gowns worn by both male and female Mongolians; boots, including the traditional Mongolian style with the bizarrely turned up toe; bronze Buddhas, incense burners, butter lamps, wall hangings, and other religious paraphernalia; fox, bear, and wolf skins; old Mongolian coins and pre-revolutionary Russian rubles; and of course all manner of memorabilia—tea cups, pocket calendars, medallions, decals, tee-shirts—all emblazoned with eclipse insignia.

Circulating through the crowd were men hawking beautifully chased knives and daggers and gleaming three foot-long swords with coral and stone encrusted hafts; dozens of artists with the ubiquitous water color miniatures of rural scenes; a bevy of dolled-up teen-aged girls selling "dinosaur eggs" which appeared to be nothing more than river cobbles; dandiprats hawking hastily patched together albums of common postage stamps; and a assortment of sad sacks peddling crudely carved wooden toys, tattered postcards, single cigarettes, tiny plastic Buddhas, Lenin pins, and other detritus.
“Hey you, wanna buy a dinosaur egg?”
While the foreign eclipsers were the motivating factor for the shopping frenzy they were certainly not the only customers. Many Mongolians were taking advantage of the opportunity to trade with their compatriots assembled here from all over the country. Trucks full of huge carpets, stacks of tanned furs, reindeer hides, saddles, Buddhist wall hangings and charms, and hand-crafted investment grade silver and gold jewelry all attracted more Mongolians than tourists.

Assembled in the huge field in front of the hotel stood a half dozen camels assuming their usual look of haughty superiority. Indeed, they appeared quite regal in their thick lustrous winter coats. Nearby pranced a couple of dozen horses with riders. At first the camel and horse owners wanted money even to take pictures but soon gave up in the face of an onslaught of snap - shotters. Camel rides for foreigners were five dollars, or a dollar if you dug in your heels. Many tourists thought posing on camels was too hokey, but dozens of Mongol kids, paying discounted fees in togrogs, climbed on board to the howling laughter of their companions, The horsemen, many of them teenagers, were in full regalia—immense wolf and dog fur hats and colorful gowns and sashes—and for a buck they would pose and then let you ride one of their horses around the hotel.
Camel assuming its characteristically haughty pose
In a closed off compound by the side of the hotel were a small contingent of Tsaagan, a tiny minority group numbering only about 600 members who scratch out a precarious living herding reindeer in the mountains west of Lake Khövsgöl, near the border of Siberia, an area remote even by Mongolian standards. Someone gave them the bright idea of bringing their reindeer to Darkhan by truck—a journey which took over two weeks—and allowing them to be ridden and photographed for a fee. This started out at $45, but by late afternoon Adam Smith's "invisible hand" had come into play and the price plummeted to five and finally three dollars.
Ride’em Reindeer Girl!
Nearby was a ger set up by Kazakhs, a minority group who had spilled over into the westernmost Mongolian province of Bayan-Olgii from neighboring Kazakhstan. Inside the ger was an immense golden eagle with a wing span of at least six feet which the Kazakhs normally use to hunt down small game.
Golden Eagle
For six dollars you could don a long Kazakh robe and fur hat and be photographed holding the raptor on your arm. It had no muzzle on its huge beak and you were warned to avoid eye contact. Apparently many Mongolians had never seen these trained eagles and they too lined up to have their picture taken holding one—at a reduced price of 500 tögrögs, about seventy-five cents.
Please, do not make eye contact with the eagle!
While this circus-like atmosphere prevailed outside several techno-heads among the Boojumites had strung antennae out their hotel windows and were downloading weather maps from both American and Russian satellites. By eleven o'clock that evening the verdict was in and it was not good. In the evening hours an enormous cloud bank had hunkered over northern Mongolia and was not expected to budge for at least twenty-four hours. Heavy snow was forecast for most of the night and the early morning hours.

It was not a merry band of campers who assembled on the Boojumite buses the next morning at 6:00. We left the hotel in a flurry of snow which even the buses’ headlights had trouble cutting through. Many who had chattered non-stop for five hours on the road to Darkhan now stared gloomily ahead, lost in their own meditations. A lot would have close to $5000 wrapped up in this escapade before it was all over, and now it seemed almost certain the main event was going to be washout.

We passed the umbra's center line at 38.5 kilometers north of Darkhan and continued on another 12 kilometers to a high point known as Khamar Pass, which our leaders, on a scouting expedition the day before, had chosen as our viewing site. Someone with a GPS gave the coordinates as N49°50'757" and E106°13'683". By 7:15 a cold, gray, sun-less dawn had broken. The snow had stopped completely; the temperature was 12°F.

People scrambled up the slopes on either side of road and jockeyed for position on four or five different rocky knobs. I claimed my spot along side a stocky, bearded German with little English, a tall, gray-haired American women decked out in a purple deel she had bought in Darkhan, and a half dozen Mongolian men.

Above the ridge to the east was a thick belt of slate colored cloud through which the sun was at first just barely detectable. At exactly 7:49 someone yelled "First Contact!" This is the first moment that the sun begins to be covered by the moon. Had the sun been visible, within a few minutes we would have been able to see just a sliver shaved off its side by the encroaching moon. Precisely 59 minutes and 55 seconds later "second contact," when the moon completely covers the sun, will begin.

A solar eclipse occurs, of course, when a new moon, passing between the earth and sun, casts a shadow on the earth’s surface. The moon, orbiting the earth, comes between the earth and sun once every 29.5 days, but it's usually just above or below a straight line between the sun and earth and thus no eclipse occurs. When the moon does pass directly between the sun and the earth both a partial shadow, known as a penumbra, and a complete shadow, or umbra, result. During partial solar eclipses the penumbra darkens the earth’s surface, but the umbra passes through space just above or below the North or South Pole. The penumbra can cover a swath of earth up to 5000 miles wide, and thus partial eclipses are most often seen by the greatest number of people. There are also annular eclipses, when the umbra passes over the earth, but is not long enough to reach its surface. This happens when the moon is farther from the earth than usual and does not cover the entire sun during eclipse. What we see is a ring of sunlight around the moon.

During total solar eclipses the umbra touches the earth’s surface. Traveling at several thousand miles per hour, the umbra can darken a swath just slightly over two hundred miles wide, and only those in its path will see a total eclipse. There are on average slightly less than seventy total eclipses a century, and it has been estimated that only one human being in a thousand is at the right place at the right time to see one in the course of a life time. Many, of course, will pay big bucks to place themselves in the path of totality and thus increase their chances.

Total solar eclipses are possible only because of the odd coincidence that the sun is both 400 times the diameter of the moon and 400 times farther from the earth than the moon. Thus they appear to be of about equal size in the sky, and the moon, when in the proper position, can entirely cover the sun. If the moon, 2160 miles in diameter, were only 140 miles smaller, no total solar eclipse could occur on earth, since it could not totally block out the sun.

By 8:05, seventeen minutes after first contact, the sun had cleared the dark clouds just above the horizon and entered a lighter nacreous layer. For a brief moment it flared brightly, fanning everyone's hopes that there just might be a hole in the ceiling, but then faded again, leaving only an orange ball of indistinct shape which could comfortably be looked at with the naked eye. Only with solar viewing glasses, which cut out a lot of the light diffused by the clouds, could you just barely make out the ever-growing bite being taken out of the sun.
The gloomy scene as the moment of the eclipse approached. At this point many were wondering if they should not have waited for the next solar eclipse, which was visible in the Caribbean Islands.
Eclipses, creating the illusion of the sun being devoured by the moon, no doubt scared the bejesus out of earliest Man, and starting at least 5000 years people have wracked their brains trying to predict their occurrence and explain their significance. At least part of Stonehenge—the famous fifty-six Aubrey holes arranged in a 300' diameter ring around the main stone complex—were probably used to predict eclipses. The holes themselves date back to 2400 BC. Mayan hieroglyphic books, notably the so-called Dresden Codex, also included tables which be could used to predict eclipses. It was the Babylonians and the Assyrians, however, who made the first detailed studies of eclipses and discovered that eclipses occurred in what they called saros series; that is, from whatever moment an eclipse occurs another eclipse in the same series will occur exactly eighteen years and eleven and a third days later. There are numerous saros series which allow for the up to seventy total solar eclipses a century. The Babylonians also invented astrology, which they combined with their astronomical knowledge to create a elaborate system for divining the future, with a caste of priests whose duty it was to scan the skies and detect omens and portents.

Saros cycles do not go on forever; they last about 1200 years and include between 65 and 75 eclipses. The eclipse we were watching was the sixtieth in saros series 120, which has a total of seventy-one eclipses. The next eclipse in saros series 120 will occur on March 20 2015, and the last, the seventy-first, on July 7 2195.

At 8:38—ten minutes and fifty-five seconds before the beginning of totality at our position—just a yellowish sliver of sun could be seen through the nacreous clouds. At 8:41:18 the umbra, barreling northeastward at 4240 miles an hour and covering a swath of earth almost two hundred miles wide, crosses the border between Mongolia and Kazakhstan. Thirty-seven seconds later it sweeps over the Mongolian city of Olgii, 1050 kilometers to the west, plunging it into darkness. It's seven minutes to totality at our site and there are still no visible effects in the sky or the landscape from the approaching umbra. The yellowish sliver of sun is visibly diminishing however. At 8:46:22 the umbra passes over the city of Moron, just south of Lake Khövsgöl, 411 kilometers to the west. Now it is slowing a bit, moving at perhaps 3700 miles per hour. At two minutes and thirty seconds to totality on our knoll the atmosphere has darkened but at the same time seems curiously more pellucid. The rocky knobs nearby, the people standing on them, the straggly bushes, everything suddenly appears in high relief again the white snow background. About thirty second later a wave a frigid air washes over us from the direction of the approaching umbra, dropping the temperature five or ten degrees and chilling the sweat dripping down my backbone. Someone yells "One Minute!" The southeastern horizon darkens ominously and the light at our location dims. At 8:48:55 the umbra, now 197.00 miles wide, sweeps over us at 3571 miles an hour.

O dark, dark, dark, amid the blaze of noon,
Irrevocably dark, total eclipse
Without all hope of day.

John Milton, "Paradise Regained"

The best available view of the eclipse at Darkhan
Totality has fallen and will continue for two minutes and twenty-four seconds. Car lights can be see on the road for miles both north and south, along with pin pricks of light-flashbulbs going off. On the northwest horizon a broad band of bright red-in effect a miniature sunset-narrows and fades as the umbra continues in that direction. At our location the sun is now totally covered by the moon and if it had not been obscured by clouds we could have seen its corona, the ionized gases that make up its atmosphere. Infinitesimally less brighter the sun itself, the corona is never seen, at least with the naked eye, except when the sun itself is blocked out by an eclipse. Then it is usually visible as a pearly white ring of light around the eclipsing moon; streamers from the corona may extend outward several diameters of the sun itself. For most serious eclipse buffs, especially photographers, the corona is the big event; they would be disappointed today.

A total eclipse of two minute and twenty-four second is not especially long; in theory totality can seven minutes and thirty-one seconds, and the longest eclipse of this century, in the South China Sea on June 20, 1955, lasted seven minutes and 7.7 seconds. About two minutes after second contact the horizon starts to lighten in the southwest. Totality ends at 9:52:48. Moments later a wall of roseate light appears on the horizon far to the southwest and sweeps over us at incredible speed, tingeing the vast snowy landscape a delicate pink. The German beside me sputtered something and several Mongolians gasped loudly. Then it was gone and we were all standing in weak, mundane daylight, as if at daybreak.
Like, uh, where’s the eclipse?
Our scattered groups slowly assembled on the slope behind our buses. A flask of cognac and a bottle of champagne appeared, but the celebration remained muted. We stood there till just after 9:56, when the moon completely parted from the sun, then boarded our buses. The party is over.

Back in Ulaan Baatar the news media soon declared the eclipse a flop. Not only had it not been visible, but the expected hordes of cash-laden visitors had not materialized. At final count only about 1600 foreigners had traveled to Darkhan. S. Batchuluun, the Mongolian organizer of the Boojumite group, opined that overall organization, despite all the planning committees, had been very poor and that a lot of Mongolian tourist companies were going to lose big bucks. (He did not include himself in this forecast.)

Predictably, one of the biggest losers was the “Great Khaan’s Dinner Show,” which had gone down in flames at the Chinggis Khaan Hotel. The producers lost 30 million tögrögs (over $36,000) and were being sued for non-payment by several of the scheduled performers. The chief organizer of the event, Ch. Erdenedalai, was hospitalized for "extreme stress" caused by the debacle. The Naraantuul Trade Company had laid in a stock of 10,000 “eclipse viewing spectacles” and sold only 2000 of them; unfortunately there are no more total eclipses scheduled for Mongolia until the year 2008. Saddest were the Tsaatan reindeer herders who did not even make enough money for their transport home. Marooned in Ulaan Baatar, they were reduced to giving reindeer rides in the city park. Several of their reindeer, not used to the relatively warm climate in Ulaan Baatar (by mid-March the temperature was climbing into the low twenties in the afternoons), soon died. One of their leaders said they hoped to be out of town by July.

The 30 million Japanese who watched the eclipse back home in Japan probably got the best deal. A Japanese film crew for NHK TV flew above the cloud cover in a helicopter and got good video of totality. Their Mongolian pilot was reported as saying that he had never seen anything "so amazing. I really didn't expect what confronted me. There were stars and a bright light shining next to the sun [probably Hale-Bopp]."

Back in February Mongolian lama and astronomer J. Gonchigsuren had predicted that if snow fell on the fifth day after the eclipse a spell of severe weather would follow. Perfectly cloudless skies reigned for four days after March 9, but on the fifth an unseasonable blizzard dumped six inches of snow on Ulaan Baatar. I trudged through mounting drifts to the Flower Hotel and logged onto to the Internet, where news sources reported the usual succession of civil and religious wars, mass murders, earthquakes, floods, famines, and epidemics, but I far as I could discern there were no unusual spikes. No major rulers had fallen, Bill and Hillary were still in the White House, none of the expected fallout from the Hale-Bopp companion had yet to appear, and the Earth appeared to be still rotating smoothly on it axis . . . but we all know what happened after that . . .

If I had been prescient enough to go to Chita, in Siberia east of Lake Baikal, instead of Darkhan, to view the eclipse I would have gotten this perfect view of the so-called Wedding Ring effect. Photo by my friend Boris Dmitriev from Irkutsk, who was prescient enough to go there.

Friday, January 26, 2007

Mongolia | Zanabazar | Cult of Tara

The First Bogd Gegeen of Mongolia Zanabazar came by his interest in Tara honestly. His previous incarnation, the Tibetan lama Taranatha, was deeply involved in the Cult of Tara. Taranatha was born in 1575 in Drong, Tibet, on the same birth-day as Padmasambhava, the founder of Buddhism in Tibet. Like Zanabazar, he was a childhood prodigy whose astounded everyone with his precociousness. “By the time he was only a year old,” one biographical account claims, “Taranatha could read and write, walk, and practice meditation without any imperfection. He also could name all the deities in any thangka, even those so worn and dirty that no one else alive could tell which deity was painted. He already could heal people from disease.”

Later Taranatha studied under numerous Tibetan gurus, including Jampa Lhundrup, Kunga Tashi, Je Draktopa, and Yeshe Wangpo. He also became a disciple of Buddhagupta, one of the very last prominent Buddhist monks in India, where Buddhism by that time had been largely supplanted by Islamic incursions and resurgent Hinduism. This peripatetic wanderer-monk had sojourned in Afghanistan, Kashmir, Ladakh, Sri Lanka, Java, East Africa, Bodhgaya in India (where Buddha had achieved Enlightenment), Assam, Burma, and northern Thailand and would have been able to inculcate in Taranatha a thorough knowledge of Buddhism as practiced outside of Tibet., Taranatha probably learned much about the history of cult of Tara, which originated in India, from Buddhagupta.

Taranatha became a staggeringly prolific writer whose collected works amounted to sixteen hefty volumes. Perhaps his most famous work was the History of Buddhism in India, completed in 1608. An “amazing intellectual performance” according to its editor, Debiprasad Chattopadhyaya, the History is still in print in English translation today. He also wrote a volume of commentary on the Kalachakra Tantra, which according to tradition had been taught by Buddha to Suchandra, the first king of the legendary realm Shambhala. He also translated from Sanskrit a guidebook to the Kingdom of Shambhala entitled Kalapar Jugpa (“The Entrance to Kalapa”, Kalapa being the capital of Shambhala) This translation was later used as the basis of the most famous guidebook to Shambhala, Description of the Way to Shambhala, written by the Third Panchen Lama Palden Yeshe in 1775. Also, in his Autobiography, the first volume of his collected works, he relates that while in a dream state a small white boy led him to Shambhala. Alone among the many sojourners who claim to have visited this storied kingdom, either in their physical bodies, in dreams, or in meditative states, Taranatha found Shambhala inhabited almost entirely by women.

Taranatha was also a chief spokesman for the so-called Jonang School, a small but vigorous sect which held doctrinal tenets in some cases decidedly different from some other schools of thought in Tibet. The basic teachings of the school had appeared early as the eleventh century, but it is Dolpopa Sherab Gyelten (1292-1361) who is credited with fully developing the Jonang belief-system. The sect is best known for its philosophical doctrine of ultimate truth called shen-tong, or “other emptiness.” This is different from the rang-tang doctrine of “self-emptiness” expounded by Nagarjuna, Chandrakirti, and other Indian teachers. Shen-tong asserts that “emptiness, in dispelling the illusive relative truths of the world, reveals an ineffable transcendental reality with positive attributes.” The rang-tang view “claimed that emptiness is merely the elimination of falsely imagined projections upon the relative truths of the world and does not imply anything else.” As Tibetologist Stephen Batchelor points out, “While such distinctions may strike us today as theological hairsplitting, in Tibet they became (and still are) crucial articles of faith.”

In addition to the shen-teng teachings, the Jonangpa had an special interest in the Kalachakra, the doctrine which supposedly first flourished in Shambhala. Numerous Jonang monks besides Taranatha wrote on the Kalachakra, and a unique line of Kalachakra teachings has been passed down to this day by the Karma Kargyu school.

In the thirteen century Kunpang Tukje Tsötru (1243-1313) founded the original Jonang Monastery, which became the seat of the Jonang Sect, about three miles up a small side valley of the Tsangpo River. Reportedly this monastery was modeled on the traditional layout of the kingdom of Shambhala as shown on Shambhala thangkas. In 1327 Dolpopa Sherab Gyelten built nearby an enormous seven-story stupa, the Jonang Kumbum, similar in appearance but older than the much more famous kumbum in the city of Gyantse.

In 1614 Taranatha established the Puntsokling Monastery three miles down the side valley from the Jonang Monastery, near the south bank of the Tsangpo. The main buildings of the monastery were built on a high knob overlooking the river and offering spectacular views up and down the valley. The Puntsokling Monastery eventually became famous for its printing workshop which among many other items published the sixteen-volume collected works of Taranatha himself. According to some accounts Taranatha went to Mongolia not long after founding Puntsokling and established several monasteries there. Almost nothing is known about his years in Mongolia and it is unclear what monasteries he may have founded in those pre-Zanabazar days. In any case, he died in Mongolia in 1634 and his body was returned to Tibet.

According to Italian Tibetologist Giuseppe Tucci, Taranatha was buried at Dzingi, five miles northeast of Oka: “A large silver chorten is said to hold the mortal remains of Taranatha, a well-known Tibetan polymath . . . As tradition has it, Taranatha’s relics were thrown into the river and carried by the stream to Katrag, midway between Zangrikangmar and Oka, where they were collected and transported into the Dzingi temple.”

The Puntsokling Monastery and Jonang sect in general fell on hard times in the early 1640s. One of the most prominent opponents of the shen-teng view espoused by the Jonangpa was Tsongkhapa, founder of the Gelug sect, and the Gelug continued in later years to take exception to the Jonang teachings. But while it is easy to imagine Jonang and Gelug monks engaging in fierce courtyard debates over these teachings it is difficult to believe that philosophical differences alone were behind the forceful takeover of the Puntsokling Monastery in 1642 by the Dalai Lama-led Gelug sect and the subsequent suppression of the Jonang school. It would appear instead that the Jonang, along with the Karma Kargyu sect, had made the political miscalculation of siding with the King of Tsang against the Fifth Dalai Lama in the civil war which broke out in Tibet in the early 1640s

According to the monks there today, the monastery was heavily damaged in 1642 by forces loyal to the Dalai Lama. Many of the printing blocks at the printing establishment were destroyed, including those of Taranatha’s own books. The monastery thereafter became a Gelug establishment with the new name of Ganden Puntsokling, and presumably the monks were converted to the Gelug sect. While the Jonang sect itself was suppressed, it should be pointed out that many of Taranatha’s writing later became fully incorporated into the teaching of the Gelug sect.

Zanabazar made the first of his two trips to Tibet in 1649, when he was fourteen years old. In 1650, after meetings with the Panchen and Dalai lamas, he set out to visit places in Tibet connected with the lives of his Previous Incarnations. The monastery of Ganden Puntsokling was one of the stops on this pilgrimage. By then it was a Gelug establishment, and no doubt the damage from the turmoils of 1642 had been repaired. While at Ganden Puntsokling Zanabazar was given a very valuable book, identified in Mongolian sources as the Ja-Damba, which was printed in gold on leaves of sandalwood. This book he took back with him to Mongolia. He probably saw the enormous (forty feet in circumference) three-dimensional Kalachakra mandala fashioned from gold and copper which was one of the main attractions at Ganden Puntsokling. According to one source it remained here until 1680, when it was finally taken to the Potala, the Dalai Lama’s palace in Lhasa, where it remains to this day as the stunning centerpiece of the Kalachakra Temple. No doubt he walked up the side valley the original Jonang Monastery and visited all seven stories and dozens of temple niches within the Jonang Kumbum. And maybe he climbed the hillside east of the Kumbum and sat in the cave which Taranatha himself had used as a meditation retreat. At Ganden Puntsokling and other monasteries on his itinerary he also collected statues of Tara, Chenresig (the Tibetan name for Avalokiteshvara), and Maitreya. These statues were taken back to Mongolia and may have served as models for his own works.

Ganden Puntsokling is off the heavily-beaten tourist path in Tibet, but monks in residence say that a fair amount of foreign tourists and pilgrims find their way there in the summertime. There were no other visitors in the wintertime when I was there. There are no tourist facilities anywhere in the area, but the monks were kind enough to let us use a guestroom and give us tea and dinner.
The ruins of Taranatha's monastery
Most of the monastery was heavily damaged during the Cultural Revolution. The castle-like building on the high knob overlooking the valley is still in ruins, but two of the temples at the base of the knob have been restored. In one of them, the Shambhala Temple, is a wooden replica, just recently constructed, of the huge three-dimensional Kalachakra mandala which had been removed from here at some point and placed in the Potala in 1680. An hour’s walk up the side-valley leads to the Lingshar Nunnery where about a dozen nuns now live. They are in the charge of huge Jonang Kumbum and act as guides for visitors. The Kumbum was also heavily damaged by the Red Guards but the exterior of the structure and some of the temple niches on its seven floors have now been restored. The fourth-floor is dedicated to one of Taranatha’s preoccupations, the Kalachakra, and the temples on this floor contain statues of some of the twenty-five Kalkin Kings of Shambhala, although most are now unrecognizable. From the top of the Kumbum is a good view of the environs of the old Jonang Monastery, supposedly modeled on Shambhala, but the buildings themselves are now almost totally in ruins. On the hillside can still be seen the cave the nuns say Taranatha used as a meditation retreat. Unfortunately they have never heard of Zanabazar, and thus are unable to say for sure if he himself ever visited here.
See More photos of Jonang
The Golden Rosary Illuminating the Origins of the Tantra of Tara, Volume 12 of Taranatha’s Collected Works, is one of the famous works about the Tara mythologem. According to Taranatha’s account, Tara was first a sentient being named Jnanachandra, the Moon of Wisdom, who lived an unfathomable number of eons before our present day, perhaps in a universe that existed before the Big Bang that produced current universe in which we now live. For countless eons Jnanachandra made offerings to a Buddha named Tathagata Dundhbhishvara and prayed for enlightenment. At long last she was able to achieve what Taranatha calls the “Thought of Enlightenment,” or bodhicitta, the desire to attain Buddhahood for the sake of all other living beings. “At that time some monks said to her, ‘It is as a result of these, your roots of virtuous actions, that you have come into being in this female form. If you pray that your deeds accord with the Teaching, then surely you will change your form to that of a man, as is befitting.’”

Jnanachandra replied,

Here there is no man, there is no woman,
No self, no person, and no consciousness.
Labeling ‘male’ or ‘female’ has no essence
But deceives the evil-minded world . . .

She continued: “There are many who desire Enlightenment in a man‘s body, but none who work for the benefits of sentient beings in the body of a woman. Therefore, until samsara is empty, I shall work for the benefit of sentient beings in a woman’s body.”

For countless eons Jnanachandra practiced her devotions. “Behaving skillfully towards objects of the five sense,” Taranatha tells us, “she practiced concentration, and thereby attained the acceptance that all dharmas are unproduced . . . and realized the samadhi called ‘Saving all Sentient Beings.’ By the power of realization, every day in the morning she then freed a million million sentient beings from worldly thoughts, and would not eat until they were established in that acceptance. Every evening also she so established a similar number. The Tathagata Dundhbhishvara, observing her devotion and compassion toward all sentient being, declared, ‘As long as you manifest the unsurpassed Enlightenment, you will be known only be the name Goddess Tara.’” Ever since Moon of Wisdom-knowledge has been known as Tara.

Then for eon after eon Tara perfected her practices while continuing to aid countless sentient beings. In the eon of Vibudda she received the names Loving Mother, Swift One, and Heroine; in another she learned to protect sentient being from the Eight Fears, and finally in the of eon of Asanka she achieved the title, “Mother of all Buddhas.”

According to Taranatha, Tara made her appearance in our world, known in Buddhist texts as Jambudvipa, a few centuries after the birth of Buddha Sakyamuni. She was thought to be an emanation of Avalokitesvara, the Bodhisattva of Compassion. Out of pity for human mired in samsara Avalokitesvara shed a tear which fell to earth and became a crystalline lake. According to legend, Tara was born out of a lotus flower that appeared on the surface of the lake. The Dalai Lamas of course are considered to be male emanations of Avalokitesvara.

In India a cult soon grew up around the idea of Tara the Protectress. Because of her compassion for sentient beings built up through countless eons she was thought to be ever ready to come to the aid of people in distress. She perhaps became most famous for protecting people from the Eight Fears, a talent she had learned, as noted earlier, in a far-distant eon before she appeared in our age. These eight objects of fear were: lions, elephants, fire, snakes, robbers, imprisonment, water, and man-eating demons. While most of these fears seem related to people of India and other southern Asian countries (fears of elephants and lions, for example), it should be pointed out that the Eight Fears also have an esoteric connotation. Each of them in order stand for pride, delusion, anger, envy, wrong views, avarice, attachment, and doubt. These are actually what Tara is supposed to protect us from.

Eventually a whole corpus of prayers, hymns, and praises evolved around Tara, Two of the most famous are called “Praise of Arya-Tara” and “The King of Praises Called the Fulfiller of All Aims, A Praise of the Arya Goddess Tara.” both attributed Matrceta, an Indian monk who allegedly lived in the second century, although considerable doubt has been raised about exactly when he lived and his authorship of the text. The first is nine verses long; a sample verse reads, the fourth, reads:

Your body, unmoved by defilements, is firm like a mountain.
Well-grown, since nourished by Your perfect virtues,
Full-breasted, since loving kindness moves your heart,
Venerable Tara—homage to You!

The second is forty-five verses long. Two verses read:

You have a body that’s green, for all activities.
On Your crown You’re adorned with Amitabha,
With the look of a universal ruler,
Tara, captain of beings, such is your body . . .

Your lovely locks are beautified with a crown,
Diadem, ribbons, crescent and double vajra.
Earrings, adornments of neck and shoulders, bracelets,
Girdle, anklets and lower-leg wrappings adorn you.

Zanabazar’s Green Tara, shown here, is a perfect objectification of the Tara described in these three verses. This Green Tara is now the Eighth Bogd Gegeen's Winter Palace in Ulaan Baatar.
In India by the sixth century images of Tara—statues, reliefs and perhaps paintings—began to appear, first shown together with Avalokitesvara and finally by herself, and eventually she was depicted in famous Buddhist cave-temples of Ellora. Thus began the long tradition of Tara portrayed in art works which lead to Zanabazar’s Taras.

In the seventh century the King of Tibet, Songtsen Gampo, acquired wives from the neighboring countries of Nepal and China. Both of were Buddhas and both became instrumental in the spread of the Dharma in Tibet. The Chinese wife was thought to be an incarnation of White Tara, the Tara of the Seven Eyes, while the Nepali wife was considered to be an incarnation of Green Tara. Both brought numerous Buddhist statues with them when they came to Tibet and it is possible that images of Tara were introduced into Tibet at this time. The Jowo Buddha statute brought by the Chinese wife, by the way, can still be seen in the Jokhang Temple in the old section of Lhasa, although the crush of people who rush the shrine when it is opened to the public can be daunting to those not accustomed to Tibetan crowd scenes.
Jokhang Temple in Lhasa
Buddhism suffered a hiatus in Tibet after the persecutions of the apostate king Langdarma (838-42), a supporter of the Bön religion who destroyed many Buddhist temples and persecuted monks and lay believers. Within the space of the few years the Dharma all but disappeared. Not until the eleventh century, with the appearance of Atisha and other Indian masters did it finally recover.

Atisha (982–1054) had been born Prince Candragarbha, the second son of King Kalyanasri, ruler of a small Indian kingdom in what is now Bangladesh. According to one account of his life, as a young man he had a vision of Tara in which she advised him to renounce his royal title and seek a guru in another country. After years of study in various part of India he sought out teachers in Sumatra, where he lived from 1013 to 1025. Upon his return to India he did stints at the monasteries of Nalanda, Odantapuri, Somapuri, and Vikramasila and soon became recognized as one of the greatest teachers of his age.

While at Vikramasila during the years 1036–1040 Atisha worked with a Tibetan named Nak-ts’o who had come to India to study the Dharma and translate Sanskrit Buddhist texts his own language. Atisha and Nak-ts’o worked together to translate into Tibetan “The Pearl Garland, A Praise of the Goddess Arya Tara”, a forty-three verse praise which had been was written by the Indian monk Candragomin in the seventh century. This later became one of the primary texts of the Tara cult in Tibet Verses four and six:

With magical body of space, unobstructed,
You cross with compassion samara’s great ocean,
And conduct migrators to the land
Of Liberation, great Captain—homage!

Subduing with mantras hostile gods,
Taking Your image upon one’s crown
Becomes a cause to achieve the four rites,
You of power unimpeded—homage!

In 1040 emissaries were sent from Tibet asking Atisha to come there and help re-establish Buddhism. At first Atisha hesitated, but in yet another vision Tara, his tutelary deity, advised him that although he would shorten his life by twenty years by doing so, going to Tibet would greatly aid the spread of the Dharma. He left Vikramashila later in 1040, the following year arrived in Nepal, and was in Tholing in Western Tibet by 1042. It is Atisha we are told, “who was to establish the Buddhist religion in Tibet once and for all . . .” Indeed, his fundamental lamrim text Lamp for the Way of Enlightenment is still in print and read today. The school which grew up around him, the Kadam sect, eventually developed into the so-called New Kadam, or Gelug sect, to which the Dalai Lamas and Zanabazar in his later life belonged. He was also instrumental in spreading the Tara cult in Tibet. Taraist Martin Willson points out, “. . . it would seem that her name was constantly on his lips and that She frequently helped him. There is hardly a significant event in this life that one or other of his biographers fails to connect with the Goddess. Thanks to his devotion, Tara became one of the two most popular deities of Tibet.”

Although not a prolific writer on Tara, Atisha did write at least one praise to Tara and three sadhanas (tantric rites devoted to a particular deity). The eleven verse praise read in part:

To those tired of circling long,
again and again, among the
Six Destinies, you grant the rest,
supremely pleasant, of Great Bliss

Goddess who works the weal of others!
Just to think of You dispels problems!
You, endowed with love and compassion,
liberate from samsara’s bonds . . .

Drolma Lhakhang (Tara Temple), where Atisha spent the last years of his life and where he died, is located about twenty miles from Lhasa on the main road to Shigatse Every visitor who arrives in Tibet via airplane passes by this temple on the way from the airport to Lhasa, but very few seem to stop, and it is not appear to be on the itinerary of guided tours. The first time I was there it was not even necessary to buy a ticket to visit the temple, a rarity in Tibet (two years a ticket was required.) It’s relative obscurity is puzzling, since it contains some of the oldest extant Buddhist statues in Tibet. Unlike almost all over temples in Tibet it was not damaged during the Cultural Revolution and most of its contents survived in tact. According to local monks the Bangladesh government made a direct please to the Communist authorities in Beijing to protect the temple of Atisha, who is considered a saint in his homeland, and as a result a unit of the PLO protected it against the rampages of the Red Guards. (I have never been able to confirm this story independently, but it’s clear the temple and its contents were not significantly damaged.) On the outside of the front wall, to the right of the entrance to the center temple, is a large painting of Tara, Atisha’s tutelary deity, and in the center temple itself is a large Tara surrounded by the other Twenty-One Taras.
White Tara on the front wall of Atisha’s Temple
These have a more than passing resemblance to the Twenty-One Taras made by Zanabazar and now on display in the Winter Palace. A statue of Tara which Atisha himself brought from India used to be here in this temple but it has since disappeared, no one knows how or where. The temple to the right, although not directly unconnected with Tara, contains huge statues of Amitayus, the past Buddhas Kashyapa and Dipamkara, and the Eight Great Bodhisattvas, all dating back to the eleventh century and untouched by Mao’s Little Generals. Here you can get an inkling of what temples in Tibet must have looked like before the iconoclastic upheavals of the late 1960s. Incidentally, sometime during that turbulent decade Atisha’s ashes, which were kept in an urn in the central temple, were returned for safekeeping to Bangladesh, where presumably they remain today.
The New Kadam, or Gelug sect, a continuation of the Kadam tradition initiated by Atisha, was founded by the great reformer Tsongkhapa (1357–1437) This is the sect to which Zanabazar would later belong. One of Tsongkhapa’s two main disciples was Gedün Drup (1391-1475), who was posthumously given the title of First Dalai Lama after the Tibetan lama Sonam Gyatso had been given the title of Dalai Lama by the Mongolian chieftain Altan Khan in 1578 (Sonam Gyatso became the Third Dalai Lama, the second, Gendun Gyatso, was also given the title posthumously.) Gendün Drup received extensive teachings on Tara from a number of celebrated gurus and went on to write a “A Praise of the Venerable Lady Khadiravani Tara Called the Crown Jewel of the Wise,” and various other Tara-related works. Also, Tara supposedly appeared before him while he was meditating. ”It is said he always consulted Her before undertaking anything,” avers Taraist Martin Willson.

Perhaps then Tara had a say when in 1447 Gendün Drup established Tashilhunpo Monastery in the city of Shigatse. This went on to become one of the largest and most influential monasteries in Tibet. In the mid-seventeenth century the head of Tashilhunpo was a lama named Losang Chökyi Gyeltsen (1570-1662). This distinguished lama had begun studying at Tashilhunpo when he was seventeen and became abbot of the monastery at the age of thirty-one. In 1604 he journeyed to Drepung Monastery in Lhasa and served as the tutor and ordinator of the 4th Dalai Lama Yönten Gyatso. After the 4th Dalai Lama passed away in 1616 Losang Chökyi Gyeltsen led the search for his reincarnation and was instrumental in choosing Ngawang Lobsang Gyatso as the 5th Dalai Lama. He gave the young Dalai Lama his novice ordination in 1625 and his full ordination in 1638, and became his principal teacher. Later, after the Fifth Dalai Lama had achieved both spiritual and temporal control of Tibet, he declared that Losang Chökyi Gyeltsen was a manifestation of the Buddha Amitabha. Since an abbot of Tashilhunpo was traditionally known as a Panchen (“great scholar”), the Dalai Lama gave Ngawang Lobsang Gyatso the official title of Panchen Lama and also recognized as Panchen Lamas a line of three previous incarnations leading back to Khedrup Je, one of Tsongkhapa’s two chief disciples. Thus Ngawang Lobsang Gyatso became the 4th Panchen Lama, according to some reckonings, but still considered the first by many.

When Zanabazar made his first trip to Tibet in 1649 at the age of fourteen he met with both the Panchen Lama Losang Chökyi Gyeltsen and Ngawang Lobsang Gyatso, the Fifth Dalai Lama. He received numerous initiations and teachings from both, and although the record does not specifically say so we might assume that these included practices on Tara. As mentioned, he also traveled to the monastery of his previous incarnation Taranatha, author of The Golden Rosary Illuminating the Origins of the Tantra of Tara. Atisha’s Tara Temple is on the road from Lhasa to Shigatse and it’s tempting to think of Zanabazar stopping there to admire the Tara statute which Atisha had brought from India and the other Twenty-One Taras on display, but we have no proof that he did so. In any case, it might be averred that by the end of his first visit to Tibet he had acquired a thorough grounding in the whole Tara mythologem.

Just as important for Zanabazar’s immediate future, the Dalai Lama finally managed to convert him to his own Gelug sect and for the first time officially recognize him as an incarnation of Jebtsun Damba. For a fifteen year old to be told that he was the latest appearance in a spiritual lineage dating back to the time of Buddha must have been a heady experience. Indeed, Zanabazar was so deeply impressed by his experiences in Tibet that he wanted to stay in the country indefinitely. During one of his visits to Tashilhunpo he had told the Panchen Lama, “I wish to settle in Tibet and undergo instruction.” According to the Rosary of White Lotuses, the Panchen Lama finally had to tell him, “It will be much more beneficial to the Teachings and sentient beings if you go back to the Sog country [Mongolia] and set up new monasteries there, rather than stay and study here.” At some point he also intimated to the Dalai that he would like to stay in Tibet, but the Great Fifth gave him the same answer as the Panchen Lama: he could do the most good for sentient beings in Mongolia.

So Zanabazar tried to make the most of his limited time in Tibet. The construction of the Potala, the Dalai Lama’s great palace which to this day looms over Lhasa, was in progress while he was in Tibet, and there were many artists from Nepal and other countries in the Tibetan capital to assist in the construction of new building and to create new art work for its furnishing.
The Potala in Lhasa
Although the Mongolian accounts say nothing of this, it is possible that Zanabazar, who had shown marked artistic inclinations from early childhood, used this opportunity to acquaint himself with the techniques employed by these various artisans. In any case, art historians would later detect Nepalese influence in many of his most famous works. It’s also possible that at this time he became acquainted with the theoretical canons of art contained in the Tengyur, the vast collection of commentaries on the Buddha’s teachings.

While in Lhasa, Zanabazar stayed at Drepung Monastery, which as we have seen had been founded in 1416 by one of his previous incarnations, Jamyang Chöje Tashi. Pelden. The Gomang College at Drepung was traditionally where Mongolians monks who came Tibet to study stayed and it eventually became famous for its Mongolian scholars. Drepung continues to be an important pilgrimage site for Tibetans, as well as a standard stop on all tourist excursions in Lhasa. I have visited Drepung several times. Once I was there in the winter when the courtyards and hallways were jammed with Tibetan pilgrims from the countryside. On this occasion I had the benefit of a guide and translator, a Tibetan woman in her thirties who spoke excellent English. I explained to her that I would like to ask someone at Drepung whether they knew anything about Zanabazar, the famous Mongolian lama who had visited here in the mid-seventeenth century. I had intended that she ask someone in a position of authority about this, but instead she immediately turned to an old toothless monk who happened to be shuffling by and put the question to him. He was hard of hearing and my translator ended up shouting at him while he cupped his hands to his ears in order to hear. Immediately a crowd of pilgrims gathered around us to see what all the commotion was about. He finally understand her question and after ruminating at length, all the while twirling the half-dozen or so white hairs which constituted his beard, said “Oh,“ you must mean the famous Mongolian lama whose 9th reincarnation now lives in India.” Amazing, he was indeed referring to Zanabazar, whose current reincarnation is now headquartered at a monastery in Simla, India. I was startled to hear that he knew about Zanabazar, but even more so that he aware of Zanabazar’s present reincarnation. “Ask him how he knows about the reincarnation in India,” I told my translator. After another shouting match she replied, “He heard about this lama on BBC.”

“Come,” said the monk, “I’ll show you where Zanabazar lived.” He led us up some cobbled pathways to the back of the monastery and pointed to a mass of ruined walls and rubble covering the hillside. “Zanabazar lived in one of those buildings, but it were destroyed back during the troubles,” he said, referring to the Cultural Revolution. Unfortunately the monk could tell us nothing more about Zanabazar’s stay in Lhasa during his first trip to Tibet, but it seems significant that even the humblest of the monastery’s current inhabitants remember his presence at Drepung.
Ruins of the building Zanabazar lived in at Drepung
Interesting as his stay in Tibet must have been it was soon time to return to Mongolia. On the Dalai Lama’s advice he took with him numerous Tibetan monks and fifty Tangut monks from the Kingdom of Xi Xia (roughly the modern-day province of Ningxia, China).
Statue of Xi Xia Monk in the Ningxia Provincial Museum
All of them were members of the Gelug sect and were to assist Zanabazar in converting Mongolia to the Yellow Hat Faith, as the Gelug were also known.
Xi Xia Tantric Art in the Ningxia Provincial Museum
In addition to the monks were an assortment of artists, painters, and other craftsmen to help Zanabazar build and adorn new monasteries in Mongolia, including Sardgiin Khiid. In total over 600 people accompanied Zanabazar back in Mongolia, in addition to his own entourage. From the artists among them he may have acquired the skills needed to create his Taras and other works. They arrived sometime in 1651, exact date unknown. The seeds of Tara had no doubt been sown in his mind, and they would later flower as the Taras here in the Eighth Bogd Khan’s Winter Palace.

For more on Zanaabazar’s career in Mongolia see Guide to Locales in Mongolia Connected with Life of Zanabazar, First Bogd Gegeen of Mongolia.

Tuesday, January 23, 2007

India | Darjeeling | Madame Blavatsky | Mahatmic Intrigue

Along with being famous for Tea and The Final Resting Place of Csoma de Koros, Darjeeling is invariably connected with the so-called Mahatmas, or Ascended Masters, the spiritual teachers first unleashed on the unsuspecting world in the latter half of the nineteenth century by the Russian traveler, writer, co-founder of the Theosophical Society, world-class adventuress, and Fairy Godmother of the New Age movement Madame Helena Petrovna Blavatsky, often referred to by her followers as H.P.B.
Madame Helena Petronova Blavatsky

According to H.P.B. the Mahatmas were highly evolved spiritual entities who had taken human form and were acting as her gurus. The Theosophical Society was based in part on the teachings of these Mahatmas as relayed to the general public by Madame Blavatsky and in Hundreds of Letters to various people that they allegedy wrote, many of which were eventually collected and published in book form. During her lifetime Madame Blavatsky managed to convince her huge and influential following of the existence of the Mahatmas, although sceptics maintained that they never existed outside of her own legendarily fecund imagination and that the letters which supposedly emanated from them were written by H.P.B. herself.

If, however, the Mahatmas were inventions of Madame Blavatsky’s, they should have vanished from the scene when she herself transmigrated in 1891. Instead, to the intense frustration of Madame Blavatsky’s innumerable detractors, they refused to disappear and instead took on a life of their own, continuing to write letters and appear either in material or astral form to those who had taken up the Theosophical torch. Many later adherents of Theosophy, including Nicholas Roerich and his wife Helena Roerich (given their Shambhalic Proclivities it was inevitable that both of them would eventually show up in Ulaan Baatar) continued to believe explicitly in the Mahatmas. Hundreds, perhaps thousands, of books, articles, and pamphlets have been written about them, both pro and con, and indeed the dispute about their existence rages on to this day, as any search on the internet will very quickly reveal.

In Madame Blavatsky’s day Darjeeling was a hotbed of Mahatmic intrigue. Madame Blavatsky herself had been taken there by the Mahatmas, in particular Morya, or Master M. as he was sometimes called.
Morya
Although numerous Mahatmas would surface over the years the two most prevalent, and certainly the two busiest letter writers were Master Morya and Koot Hoomi.
Koot Hoomi
One of the more celebrated meetings with a Mahatma took place near Darjeeling, between one of Madame’s Indian acolytes, a young man named S. Ramaswamier, and Master Morya.
Henry Steele Olcott - a respectable New York lawyer (or at least as respectable as a lawyer can be) who after Madame Blavatsky cast her spell on him moved to India, grew a Santa Claus beard, and started going bare-footed.
Madame Blavatsky and her co-conspirator, the American lawyer Henry Steele Olcott, had founded the Theosophical Society in New York City in September of 1875. In December of 1878 Madame Blavatsky—by that time a naturalized American citizen (the first Russian woman to achieve that honor)—and Olcott decamped to Bombay, India, where they hoped to find more fecund grounds for the flowering of the Theosophical Society. They soon attracted a sizable contingent of both Indian and British followers. Among the Indians was Ramaswamier, a young clerk from the city of Tinnevelly. During a visit to the Theosophical Headquarters in Bombay in September of 1881 Ramaswamier claimed to have seen a materialization of Master Morya, and shortly thereafter he received a letter from the Master welcoming him as an chela, or acolyte, in the Himalayan Brotherhood. “Upasika [“female disciple,” the Masters’ name for Madame Blavatsky] has all the instructions. Let my chela [Ramaswamier] follow the instruction he will receive from her,” Master M. told him in a letter. Like many chelas and other Theosophy camp followers Ramaswamier was extremely eager to see and converse with the Masters, and he apparently began badgering Madame Blavatsky, who was in communication with them, to arrange a meeting. At some point he must have threatened to go to Tibet in search of the Masters himself if Madame Blavatsky would not faciliate an encounter. In response, Ramaswamier received another Mahatma letter sometime in September of 1882: “YOU cannot go to Tibet . . .” Master M. admonished him, “You must first show that you deserve it by labouring in that direction for two or three years. You must be prepared to do anything told to you, anything you are ordered through her [Madame Blavatsky]. If you have faith in us—others have not—are you prepared to do all and everything to prove our existence?” If Madame Blavatsky was, as her legions of detractors maintained, the actual author of the various letters from the Mahatmas, then instructions like these were just fairly simply ploys to ensure the obedience of her followers. As it turned out, Ramaswamier was “prepared to do all and everything to prove” the existence of the Masters.”

About this time Ramaswamier had a physical and mental breakdown. He applied for and was granted a medical leave of absence from his job.“One day in September last,” he later wrote, “while I was reading in my room, I was ordered by the audible voice of my blessed Guru, M——Maharsi, to leave all and proceed immediately to Bombay, whence I had to go in search of Madame Blavatsky wherever I could find her and follow her wherever she went. Without losing a moment, I closed up all my affairs and left for the station.”

In Bombay he discovered that Madame had become very ill and had suddenly decamped from the city several days earlier. As Ramaswamier himself later related:
Really not knowing whither I had best go, I took a through ticket to Calcutta; but, on reaching Allahabad, I heard the same well-known voice [Master M.?] directing me to go to Berhampore. At Azimgunge, in the train, I met, most providentially I may say, with some Babus (I did not then know they were also Theosophists since I had never seen any of them), who were also in search of Madame Blavatsky. Some had traced her to Dinapore, but lost her track and went back to Berhampore. They knew, they said, she was going to Tibet and wanted to throw themselves at the feet of the Mahatmas to permit them to accompany her. At last, as I was told, they received from her a note, informing them to come if they so desired it, but that she herself was prohibited from going to Tibet just now. She was to remain, she said, in the vicinity of Darjeeling and would see the BROTHERS on the Sikkim Territory, where they would not be allowed to follow her. . .
Although it would appear he had found the trail of the elusive Madame Blavastky, for whom he was so diligently searching, Ramaswamier decided for some reason to continued on to Calcutta. Here he met with a “Brother Nobin,” president of the local Theosophical Society. Nobin, relates Ramaswamier, “would not tell me where Madame Blavatsky was, or perhaps did not then know himself. Yet he and other had risked all in hopes of seeing the Mahatmas.” Apparently Nobin soon got intimations of her whereabouts, since on 23 September he took Ramaswamier to the city of Chandernagore, just north of Calcutta, where they were promptly united with the frustratingly evasive Madame Blavatsky. She had little to say to the hapless Ramaswamier, but a man with her who he assumed was a Tibetan informed him, Ramaswamier, that he was too late, “that Madame Blavatsky had already seen the Mahatmas and that he had brought her back.” Nevertheless Ramaswamier, Nobin, and assorted other camp followers were now determined to follow Madame Blavatsky where ever she might go. There followed a bizarre series of events—trains mysteriously leaving ahead of schedule, connections inexplicable missed, and so on—which again separated the Theosophical seekers from their leader. Ramaswamier explains:
It requires no great stretch of imagination to know that Madame Blavatsky had been or was, perhaps, being again taken to the BROTHERS, who, for some good reasons best known to them, did not want us to be following and watching her. Two of the Mahatmas, I had learned for a certainty, were in the neighbourhood of British territory; and one of them was seen and recognised—by a person I need not name here—as a high Chutuktu [?] of Tibet.
Finally, however, Madame Blavatsky with her band of acolytes in tow reached Darjeeling. Here Madame shut herself up in house of a Bengalese Theosophist and refused to talk to any of the party who had followed her, including Ramaswamier. No matter, however; on or about September 30 Ramaswamier got a letter from Master M. with explicit instructions written in the third person:
RAMASWAMIER will don the robes of a regular Vedantin ascetic—even to the top-knot if necessary, and send his useless clothes to Bombay. He must travel from town to town along the line to Allahabad, and preach Theosophy and Vedantism. Every one must know he is my chela, and that he has seen me in Sikkim. He must let Upasika know of his movements constantly, and finally join her at Allahabad—as also receive my orders through her. His whole aspiration and concern must be directed towards one aim—convince the world of our existence.
The point to remember here is that Master M is telling the impressionable Ramaswamier about their meeting before it even occurred, thus making it appear that such an encounter was pre-ordained. Yet Madame Blavatsky herself refused to offer any assistance. “To all our importunities,” Ramaswamier wrote, “we could get only this answer from her: that we had no business to stick to and follow her, that she did not want us, and that she had no right to disturb the Mahatmas, with all sorts of questions that concerned only the questioners, for they knew their own business best.”

If, as her armies of detractors maintained, Madame Blavatsky was the inventor of the Mahatmas and their letters were in fact her productions then this whole series of events was a masterful pyschological ploy. She had managed to assemble a whole group of Theosophists in Darjeeling, all the while maintaining she did not want them here, and then herself refused their heart’s desire—meeting the Mahatmas—while in a letter to Ramaswamier intimating that such an encounter was inevitable. It’s no wonder that Ramaswamier was confused. He was, after all, not only on medical leave for physical and mental exhaustion but had also just traveled helter-skelter coast-to-coast across India upon the instruction of “voices” and mysteriously delivered letters. “In despair, I determined, come what might, to cross the frontier which is about a dozen miles from here, and find the Mahatmas, or-DIE,” he wrote. “I never stopped to think that what I was going to undertake would be regarded as the rash act of a lunatic.”

“October 5, I set out in search of the Mahatmas,” wrote Ramaswamier. “I had an umbrella, and a pilgrim’s staff for sole weapons, with a few rupees in my purse. I wore the yellow garb and cap. Whenever I was tired on the road, my costume easily procured for me for a small sum a pony to ride.” He was bound for Sikkim, the border of which was at that time about a dozen miles north of Darjeeling, even though he had no permit to enter the country and would face arrest if caught. That afternoon he tried to cross the Ranjit River via the swaying suspension bridge, but soon lost his nerve and took the ferry instead. Soon the path narrowed and he was in thick jungle. “I met on the road, in the afternoon, a leopard and a wild cat;” he wrote, “and I am astonished now to think how I should have felt no fear then nor tried to run away. Throughout, some secret influence supported me. Fear or anxiety never once entered my mind. Perhaps in my heart there was room for no other feeling but an intense anxiety to find my Guru.” At nighfall he happened upon by sheer luck an uninhabited two-room cabin. The door was locked but a rear window proved to be unbolted. “By a strange coincidence of circumstances,” he noted, “the hillman had forgotten to fasten it on the inside when he locked the door! Or course, after what has subsequently transpired I now, through the eye of faith, see the protecting hand of my Guru everywhere around me.”

His sleep was interrupting by the arrival of two or three people who took up residence in the adjoining room, unaware of his presence. He was terrified that they were robbers who might murder him for his admittedly few ruples, or, alternately, that he would be mistaken for the robber and they would kill him to protect themselves. After a harrowing night he managed to sneak back out the window at the first light of dawn and continue on his way. Here Ramaswamier must be quoted at length, since his account is one of the few detailed descriptions of an alleged meeting with a Mahatma in the flesh, in this case Master Morya:
It was, I think, between eight and nine a.m. and I was following the road to the town of Sikkhim whence, I was assured by the people I met on the road, I could cross over to Tibet easily in my pilgrim’s garb, when I suddenly saw a solitary horseman galloping towards me from the opposite direction. From his tall stature and the expert way he managed the animal, I thought he was some military officer of the Sikkhim Rajah. Now, I thought, am I caught! He will ask me for my pass and what business I have on the independent territory of Sikkhim, and, perhaps, have me arrested and—sent back, if not worse. But—as he approached me, he reined the steed. I looked at and recognized him instantly . . . I was in the awful presence of him, of the same Mahatma, my own revered Guru whom I had seen before in his astral body, on the balcony of the Theosophical Headquarters! It was he, the “Himalayan BROTHER” of the ever memorable night of December last, who had so kindly dropped a letter in answer to one I had given in a sealed envelope to Madame Blavatsky—whom I had never for one moment during the interval lost sight of—but an hour or so before! The very same instant saw me prostrated on the ground at his feet. I arose at his command and, leisurely looking into his face, I forgot myself entirely in the contemplation of the image I knew so well, having seen his portrait (the one in Colonel Olcott’s possession) a number of times. I knew not what to say: joy and reverence tied my tongue. The majesty of his countenance, which seemed to me to be the impersonation of power and thought, held me rapt in awe. I was at last face to face with “the Mahatma of the Himavat” and he was no myth, no “creation of the imagination of a medium,” as some sceptics suggested. It was no night dream; it is between nine and ten o’clock of the forenoon. There is the sun shining and silently witnessing the scene from above. I see HIM before me in flesh and blood; and he speaks to me in accents of kindness and gentleness. What more do I want? My excess of happiness made me dumb. Nor was it until a few moments later that I was drawn to utter a few words, encouraged by his gentle tone and speech. His complexion is not as fair as that of Mahatma Koot Hoomi; but never have I seen a countenance so handsome, a stature so tall and so majestic. As in his portrait, he wears a short black beard, and long black hair hanging down to his breast; only his dress was different. Instead of a white, loose robe he wore a yellow mantle lined with fur, and, on his head, instead of a pagri, a yellow Tibetan felt cap, as I have seen some Bhootanese wear in this country. When the first moments of rapture and surprise were over and I calmly comprehended the situation, I had a long talk with him. He told me to go no further, for I would come to grief. He said I should wait patiently if I wanted to become an accepted Chela; that many were those who offered themselves as candidates, but that only a very few were found worthy; none were rejected—but all of them tried, and most found to fail signally, especially—and—. Some, instead of being accepted and pledged this year, were now thrown off for a year . . . The Mahatma, I found, speaks very little English—or at least it so seemed to me—and spoke to me in my mother-tongue—Tamil. He told me that if the Chohan permitted Madame B. to go to Pari-jong next year, then I could come with her . . . The Bengalee Theosophists who followed the “Upasika” (Madame Blavatsky) would see that she was right in trying to dissuade them from following her now. I asked the blessed Mahatma whether I could tell what I saw and heard to others. He replied in the affirmative and that moreover I would do well to write to you and describe all . . .
Ramaswamier immediately turned around and headed back to Darjeeling, arriving late that evening completely exhausted by his two day ordeal. “I could neither eat, nor sit, nor stand. Every part of my body was aching,” he declared. He immediately went to see Madame Blavatsky, who was spending the evening with other members of the Theosophical Society. “At their prayer and Madame Blavatsky’s command, I recounted all that had happened to me, reserving of course my private conversation with the Mahatma . . . They were all, to say the least, astounded!”

We have no further description of Madame Blavatsky’s reaction, but she must have been very pleased by the performance of her acolyte. He had met Master Morya in Sikkim just as he had been instructed to do in the letter he had received earlier. His account was duly published in December issue of Madame Blavatsky’s journal The Theosophist under the title “How a ‘Chela’ Found His ‘Guru,”’ and became one of the main “proofs” of the existence of the Mahatmas, although of course there were no witnesses but Ramaswamier himself. Ramaswamier stuck to his story for the rest of his life. “And now that I have seen the Mahatma in the flesh,” he declared, “and heard his living voice, let no one dare say to me that the BROTHERS do not exist. Come now whatever will, death has no fear for me, nor the vengeance of enemies; for what I know, I KNOW!

No novelist would dare create a character like Madame Blavatsky. She was definitely sui generis. Marion Meade has waded into the morass of myth and legends swirling around H.P.B. and emerged with a fairly cogent and wonderfully entertaining biography firmly in hand. See her account of Madame Blavatsky's well-nigh unbelievable life: Madame Blavatsky: The Woman Behind the Myth.

Amazon.com Book Description:
“Madame Helena Blavatsky, the founder of Theosophy, was the granddaughter of a White Russian princess. She became the first internationally famous professional psychic and she was also a brilliant occult con artist who drew such figures as G. B. Shaw and William Butler Yeats into her bizarre web. A fervent flower child, she journeyed to the East in search of enlightenment almost 100 years before the hippie hegira of the 1960s.”
For less impartial accounts compiled by a True Believer see:

Read H.P.B.’s magnum opus The Secret Doctrine: